Binghamton University Research News
  • News
  • Features
  • Faculty
  • Students
  • Videos
  • Photos
  • Subscribe

Philosopher explores moral failure

By Andrew Tutino • Oct 14, 2011 • Faculty•   

In life, there are times when it is impossible to avoid moral wrongdoing.

Lisa Tessman, an associate professor of philosophy and women’s studies at Binghamton University, focuses on those moments. “In many situations, all of one’s available options are wrong,” Tessman said. “One has no clean options.”

Tessman is writing a book, “Moral Failure,” and will work on a chapter during the fall 2011 semester as part of a fellowship from Binghamton’s Institute for Advanced Studies in the Humanities. Her first book, “Burdened Virtues: Virtue Ethics for Liberatory Struggles,” published in 2005, looked at moral questions central to feminism from the perspective of Aristotelian ethics.

Tessman said she looks forward to discussing her work in philosophy with other academics outside of the field during the fellowship. “I’m really happy to be talking with other people in the humanities outside of philosophy,” Tessman said. “I want to engage a broader audience.”

The chapter Tessman is working on focuses on critiques that claim that some moral theories are “over-demanding,” and on responses to these critiques. She argues that both the critiques and the responses are misguided. “When you look at inevitable failure, it is anguishing to face impossible moral requirements,” Tessman said. Typically, the response is guilt, which she believes is an inappropriate response because there is no “correct” action possible.

The literature on how “demanding” morality is suggests that most of us should be doing much more to contribute to others’ well-being. Tessman argues that this literature assumes that all moral demands — even if they are very stringent — must be possible to satisfy. When one drops this assumption, one can ask a different question about moral life: “How difficult is it to face impossible moral requirements?” This is the question on which she will focus.

For example, in the William Styron novel (and later movie) “Sophie’s Choice,” the main character has to make an excruciating choice to select one of her two children to be executed in a concentration camp. “Anything she does is an unavoidable wrong on her part,” Tessman said. “She is racked with guilt throughout the movie. I don’t think guilt is the right feeling, but certainly anguish would fit the situation.”

Like this article? Please share!
humanitiesphilosophy
1
Training a critical eye on a British ideal
Marriage is this scientist's laboratory

You Might Also Like

  • What tiny fossils can tell us about the changing climate

  • Journal highlights Binghamton microbiologist’s work

  • Historian’s book project wins NEH backing

  • Neuroscientist named Chancellor’s Early-Career Scholar

  • N Jul 18, 2013 at 11:27 am

    i would really be interested in reading professor tessman’s forthcoming book. It certainly seems that there are certainly moral frameworks that cannot possibly satisfied. And if we take these moral frameworks seriously, it seems like guilt would be the natural response to personal moral failure. But just because it is the natural response doesn’t mean it’s the rational response. This is a fascinating topic.

Research in the news

  • Modern medicine traces its scientific roots to the Middle Ages

  • Are people born with good balance?

  • Earth to be hit by ‘widespread pest outbreaks’ — and it’s our fault

  • For EV batteries, lithium iron phosphate narrows the gap with nickel, cobalt

  • The revolt of the other mothers

Recent Comments

  • Resume Format on Computer program spots narcissistic execs
  • Ann Walker on Wasps may provide climate change insights
  • Dejen Habtom on Ancient seawater may yield climate change insights
  • Don Franck on Binghamton battery project wins $500,000; will compete for $100M
  • Dave on Anechoic chamber puts sound to the test
Binghamton University Binghamton University

© 2025 Binghamton University State University of New York
Images used throughout this site are copyright protected. For permission and terms of use, visit the about us page